Freestanding ER marketing: EMTALA, surprise billing and wait-time claims

A freestanding emergency department can look like an urgent care clinic from the street: a small building in a shopping center, a sign, a parking lot. Legally it is a different kind of place, and the words on that sign, in its ads and on its website carry duties an urgent care clinic does not have. Federal rules on emergency screening, emergency billing and advertising all reach the marketing of a freestanding ER, and in one case the advertising itself can decide which rules apply.

This guide is for owners, administrators and marketing leads at freestanding emergency departments, whether hospital owned or independent, and for hospitals planning an off-campus emergency site. If you run an urgent care clinic, our urgent care marketing guide covers how to keep urgent care and emergency care distinct. The homepage notice about surprise bills is covered in our guide to the No Surprises Act website disclosure, and estimates for self-pay patients in our good faith estimate guide. For NHLBI wording on when sickle cell pain needs emergency care, see sickle cell center marketing. For publishing wait times and online check-in, see ER wait time advertising.

Two kinds of freestanding ER

The first kind is a department of a hospital that happens to sit off the main campus. The EMTALA regulation defines a dedicated emergency department as “any department or facility of the hospital, regardless of whether it is located on or off the main hospital campus,” that meets one of three tests (42 CFR 489.24(b)). The EMTALA statute places its duties on a “participating hospital,” which it defines as “a hospital that has entered into a provider agreement” with Medicare (42 U.S.C. 1395dd(e)(2)). The regulation’s definition also names critical access hospitals and rural emergency hospitals (42 CFR 489.24(b)).

The second kind is an independent freestanding emergency department. The surprise billing rules define it as a health care facility that “is geographically separate and distinct and licensed separately from a hospital under applicable State law” and that provides emergency services (45 CFR 149.30). Whether the federal EMTALA duties reach a particular independent facility depends on whether it is part of a participating hospital. That is a question for counsel, and the answer should be settled before anyone writes a word about payment or screening.

The two kinds share one thing: the federal surprise billing protections for emergency services apply at “an emergency department of a hospital or an independent freestanding emergency department” (45 CFR 149.410(a)). So the billing section below applies to both.

Your advertising can make a department an emergency department

This is the point marketers miss. Under 42 CFR 489.24(b), a hospital department or facility is a dedicated emergency department if it meets at least one of these tests:

1. Licensing. It is licensed by the state “as an emergency room or emergency department.”
2. Holding out. It is “held out to the public (by name, posted signs, advertising, or other means) as a place that provides care for emergency medical conditions on an urgent basis without requiring a previously scheduled appointment.”
3. Volume. In the prior calendar year, based on a representative sample of visits, at least one third of its outpatient visits were for emergency medical conditions on an urgent basis without a scheduled appointment.

The second test is about marketing. A hospital that opens an off-campus walk-in site and advertises it as a place for emergencies can bring that site within the definition through the name, the sign or the ads alone. For a hospital, that is a reason to decide what the site is before the marketing plan is written, and to keep the ads, the sign and the website consistent with that decision. A walk-in site meant to be urgent care should not use emergency language. A site meant to be an emergency department should be built, staffed and run as one.

Screening comes before payment questions

For a hospital with an emergency department, EMTALA requires an appropriate medical screening examination for any individual who comes to the emergency department and requests examination or treatment, “whether or not eligible for Medicare benefits and regardless of ability to pay” (42 CFR 489.24(a)(1)). If an emergency medical condition exists, the hospital must provide stabilizing treatment or an appropriate transfer (489.24(a)(1)(ii)).

The statute adds that a participating hospital “may not delay provision of an appropriate medical screening examination … in order to inquire about the individual’s method of payment or insurance status” (42 U.S.C. 1395dd(h)). The regulation allows “reasonable registration processes,” including asking about insurance, “as long as that inquiry does not delay screening or treatment,” and says those processes “may not unduly discourage individuals from remaining for further evaluation” (42 CFR 489.24(d)(4)(iv)). It also bars seeking, or directing a patient to seek, insurance authorization for screening or stabilization until after screening and the start of stabilizing treatment (489.24(d)(4)(ii)).

Marketing copy and phone scripts are part of what a patient hears before arrival, so read them with those rules in mind. For an EMTALA-covered department:

• Do not tell people to bring payment or an insurance card “before you can be seen,” or suggest that uninsured people should go elsewhere.
• Do not say “call your insurance for approval first.” The regulation bars directing a patient to seek authorization for screening or stabilization before it happens, and 45 CFR 149.110(b)(1) bars plans covering emergency services from requiring prior authorization.
• Put payment and insurance information on its own page, not inside the instructions for what to do in an emergency.
• If a phone line, chat or AI receptionist answers questions, have it tell anyone describing an emergency to call 911 or come in, and keep it from asking about insurance before giving that instruction. Our new patient phone script guide covers scripting.

Signs inside, and what the website can echo

A hospital with an emergency department must post conspicuously, in the emergency department and in places likely to be noticed by people entering it or waiting for examination and treatment, “a sign (in a form specified by the Secretary) specifying rights of individuals” under the EMTALA section of the Social Security Act, and information on whether it participates in the Medicaid program (42 CFR 489.20(q)). The rule speaks of signs on site. It does not mention websites, so a website page is not a substitute for the signs.

A website can still echo the same message in plain words: everyone who comes in asking for emergency care gets a medical screening exam. Only publish that line if it is true of your facility, and have counsel review the wording against your status.

Insurance, networks and surprise bills

For people with group health plans or individual health insurance, 45 CFR 149.110(b) requires plans that cover emergency services to cover them without prior authorization, “even if the services are provided on an out-of-network basis,” and without higher cost sharing for out-of-network emergency services than for in-network ones. Under 45 CFR 149.410(a), a nonparticipating emergency facility, which includes an independent freestanding emergency department, “must not bill, and must not hold liable” the patient for more than that cost sharing for emergency services.

Three marketing points follow:

• Name the plans you are in network with, and keep the list current. “We accept all insurance” is a different claim from “we are in network with all plans,” and a patient reads them the same way. Our guide to insurance accepted pages covers the wording.
• If you describe the federal protections, describe them as the rule does and link to your disclosure notice. Do not promise that a patient will owe nothing, because cost sharing still applies and the rules have exceptions for some services after stabilization.
• Independent freestanding emergency departments are named in the disclosure rule at 45 CFR 149.430(a), which our No Surprises Act disclosure guide covers in full.

If you publish self-pay prices or bill a separate facility fee alongside professional fees, say so where you talk about cost. Our guides to advertising cash prices and, for hospital-owned sites, hospital price transparency cover how to present prices without misleading anyone.

Wait-time and “no wait” claims

Section 5 of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. 45, prohibits unfair or deceptive acts or practices “in or affecting commerce.” The FTC Health Products Compliance Guidance describes a deceptive ad as one with a material misrepresentation or omission likely to mislead consumers acting reasonably under the circumstances. Under the FTC Policy Statement Regarding Advertising Substantiation, objective claims need a reasonable basis before they run, and a claim that states a level of support needs at least that level.

A wait time is an objective claim that a person in pain acts on. If you advertise one:

• Base it on your own records, measured the same way each time, and keep those records.
• Say what it measures: time to triage, time to be seen by a clinician, or something else.
• If the number is live, feed it from the actual queue and show when it was last updated. If it is an average, say over what period.
• If patients are seen in order of medical need, say so next to the number.
• Drop “no wait” and “in and out in” promises unless your records show they hold for the claim as stated.

For an EMTALA-covered department, have counsel look at how a wait display and any online check-in sit next to the “unduly discourage” language in 42 CFR 489.24(d)(4)(iv). A display that leads someone with a possible emergency to leave or stay home is a patient safety question as well as a legal one.

Names, search ads and the Business Profile

The name is the first piece of marketing. Use the name your license and signs use, and keep “emergency” or “ER” out of the name of anything that is not an emergency department. If state law restricts those words, follow it. Our Business Profile guide for doctors covers naming and categories, and the urgent care guide covers why keyword-stuffed names break Google’s guidelines.

Search ads for symptom keywords reach people who may be having an emergency. Put a plain “if this is an emergency, call 911” line on the landing page, describe what the facility is and is not equipped for, and avoid copy that invites someone with chest pain or stroke symptoms to drive themselves past a closer emergency department to reach you.

Illustration: rewriting a freestanding ER landing page

Illustration. A landing page for an independent freestanding emergency department reads: “No wait ER. In and out in 20 minutes. We accept all insurance. Bring your card and copay before you are seen.” A live wait counter shows a number with no time stamp. Here is how the page could be rewritten:

1. Status first. Counsel confirms whether the facility is part of a participating hospital. The copy below follows from that answer.
2. Headline. “No wait” and “in and out in 20 minutes” come out. The headline says what the facility is and its hours, and a line says to call 911 in an emergency.
3. Insurance. “We accept all insurance” becomes a list of the plans the facility is in network with, with a link to the surprise billing notice.
4. Payment line. Removed from the emergency instructions. Payment information moves to its own page.
5. Wait counter. Kept only if it is fed by the queue, labeled with what it measures, time stamped, and paired with a note that patients are seen in order of medical need.
6. Fees. A cost section explains, in plain words, what kinds of charges a visit can include.

Checklist

• Status settled with counsel: hospital department, independent facility, or neither.
• Name, signs, ads and website consistent with that status, and with state licensing rules.
• No emergency language on anything that is not an emergency department.
• No ad, page or script that asks for payment or insurance before screening, or tells patients to get insurance approval first.
• On-site EMTALA and Medicaid participation signs posted, if 42 CFR 489.20(q) applies.
• Network list accurate and current; no “all insurance” claims that read as network claims.
• Surprise billing disclosure linked from the homepage, if 45 CFR 149.430 applies.
• Wait-time claims backed by records, labeled, dated, and free of “no wait” promises.
• Fee types explained in plain words where cost is discussed.
• A 911 instruction on landing pages, phone greetings and chat.

How we help

We build websites, local search, Google Ads and AI front desk tools for independent practices and health care facilities, with claims checked against the rules above before anything goes live. See our medical website design work. Our AI front desk is built with HIPAA in mind and sends anyone describing an emergency to 911 or your staff under rules you approve. We confirm in writing what a BAA covers before any patient information flows through a tool, and if it is not covered, we do not route patient information through it. We do not give legal or medical advice; your counsel decides how these rules apply to you. See the full list in our healthcare marketing rules guide.

Sources

• 42 U.S.C. 1395dd: Examination and treatment for emergency medical conditions and women in labor (EMTALA)
• 42 CFR 489.24: Special responsibilities of Medicare hospitals in emergency cases
• 42 CFR 489.20: Basic commitments (paragraph (q), emergency department signs)
• 45 CFR 149.30: Definitions (independent freestanding emergency department)
• 45 CFR 149.110: Preventing surprise medical bills for emergency services
• 45 CFR 149.410: Balance billing in cases of emergency services
• 15 U.S.C. 45: Unfair methods of competition unlawful
• FTC: Policy Statement Regarding Advertising Substantiation (November 23, 1984)
• FTC: Health Products Compliance Guidance (December 2022)

More in Facilities, care services and pharmacy